So Many Assessments, So Little Time
 

Janet Cumbee, Ed. D
Leadership Fellow, Cornerstone

This year our state assessment data arrived later than usual and I, as everyone else in the nation, was anxious about AYP. Our school was one of only 319 in the state that achieved AYP, and as exciting as that was, I also recognize that the benchmarks move and we will have to work even harder to achieve this status this year. Our state, as well as many others, implemented a new assessment to be administered with the SAT. Fourth and sixth grade students were tested with both instruments last year and this year grades 3-8 will be tested. Since this is a new test, we have limited information. In addition to this, we are now administering DIBELS in grades K-6. This is the first year we are using it in grades 4-6. Of course, I don't want to forget the state writing assessment for grade 5. Paris, Paris, and Carpenter (2002, p. 142) refer to these assessments as external assessments in that they are "designed, selected, and controlled by someone other than the teacher." Although these assessments are administered less frequently than classroom assessments, we know the community, state, and nation judge the quality of the school on the results of these tests.

As I sifted through the data, I also recognized the fact that in addition to these "external" assessments classroom teachers are using "internal" assessments. Internal assessments refer to those that are "designed, selected and used by teachers according to the needs of their children." (Paris, et. al, 2002, p. 142) Our internal assessments include running records, anecdotal notes, portfolios, reading and writing conferences, progress monitoring, and other assessments that individual teachers may use. Even though I recognize the significance of the standardized assessments, I know that the heart of the school are those internal assessments which teachers use daily to guide their instruction to meet the needs of the students.

In my quest to understand and use data more effectively, I search for books, articles, and people who can help. My good friend Becky recently shared a book that contained an interesting study related to assessment. (I must confess that Becky shares so much that I actually have a "Becky" file in my office and a stack of "Becky" books in my office, in my car, and by my bed.) In this study, Paris and his colleagues surveyed a group of teachers who were in "beat-the-odds" schools across the nation. These schools were Title I schools who were achieving higher on reading achievement than the other Title I schools in the state. The survey was designed to collect their perceptions of reading assessment in early elementary grades. The surveys indicated that these teachers believed that assessment is a vital part of successful teaching. These researchers state the findings of the study as follows:

  • The entire school or district must be involved in using assessment effectively. The system of assessment gains visibility and credibility among parents when it is endorsed by the entire school.
  • Teachers cannot create assessment systems alone; they need the emotional support, collaborative teamwork, and shared motivation to build a system of assessment tools that serves their students and community.
  • Effective schools have principals and administrators who provide leadership in integrating assessment with the curriculum and instruction.
  • Literacy assessments should start with a shared, conceptual view of the goals of reading assessment and the variety of tools that are available.
  • Teachers need to share practices that work.
  • Teachers need to make choices that provide a coherent set of assessment tools that can be used on a regular basis. State-level assessment batteries or standards, district outcomes or portfolios, or school-based report cards are all options that can be used to create a systematic approach to reading assessment.
  • Assessment reform in schools must involve communication and negotiation among stakeholders about the kinds of information that supports students' educational growth.
  • Administrators (and parents) need to learn how teachers use reading assessments just as much as teachers need to learn new kind of assessments.

How does this look in a Cornerstone school? External as well as internal assessments are embedded throughout the entire school. There is a consistency in these practices. Teachers and administrators talk about the assessments, chart the results, and discuss the ways they can improve their practice to meet the needs of the students. Parents and students are aware of the importance of these assessments as well as the expectations for learning associated with each assessment. The following chart is an example of students and teachers charting their progress.

Teachers are colleagues who support each other as they build their knowledge of assessment and how to use it effectively. Principals are an integral part of this support as they actively participate in and provide opportunities for teachers to extend their professional growth through common planning times, focused professional development, book studies, etc. The principal is seen as a learner too. This chart is a result of a school wide retreat on units of study in which the teachers planned a year of writing instruction at each grade level.

Administrators, local and central office, assist teachers in understanding the purposes for the assessments, in analyzing them, and in sharing best practices. Principals work to assist teachers in integrating the assessments into the daily schedule. Teachers know the principal is continuously expanding her knowledge about the curriculum, instruction, and assessment. Charts like the example below can be used to focus the discussion on assessment, to review the progress of students, and to share strategies with teachers on practices that have been successful in moving children.

Principals and literacy coaches are instrumental in developing a vision for literacy instruction in the school. The asset map and the literacy action plans are tools to support this vision. Once a vision is established the school can then determine internal assessments that measure the effectiveness of the implementation of the literacy instruction.

In reflection I know it is easy to become overwhelmed with the amount of data and with the responsibility of analyzing it, and clearly communicating it to teachers and parents. In the midst of sifting through this data, attempting to keep our thoughts clearly focused and trying not to be overwhelmed, we need to remind ourselves of the real purpose of assessment. Paris states, "At the simplest level, assessment should be a way to communicate information about children's accomplishments to others. If children's welfare is the highest educational priority, then teachers, parents, and administrators should work together to design assessment systems that bring the greatest benefits to children" (2002, p. 159). So we continue to sift and analyze and communicate and remember that if we do our job well, our children will benefit.

REFERENCES
Paris, S.G., Paris, A. H., Carpenter, R. D. (2002). Effective practices for assessing young readers. In B. M. Taylor & P. D. Pearson (Eds.), Teaching Reading: Effective Schools, Accomplished Teachers (pp. 141-160). Mahwah, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum.

For further reading, a bibliography on assessment (taken directly from the Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development website [http://www.ascd.org]) follows.

Publication
Date
Relevance
Title
Summary
Journal of Curriculum and Supervision
April 1, 1999
102
"Elementary Teachers' Beliefs About Assessment in Mathematics: A Case of Assessment Paralysis" by Ginette Delandshere and John H. Jones
Assessment is at the center of the current educational reform movement. At the same time, new perspectives on teaching, learning, and curriculum are calling for new forms of assessment. Teachers are...
"How To" Books
January 1, 1996
95
How to Use Standards in the Classroom
A book by Douglas E. Harris and Judy F. Carr (ASCD, 1996). How can you bring standards to life and reality in your classroom? This guide is for teachers who seek a model and processes for designing...
Educational Leadership
September 1, 2002
64
"Classroom Assessment for Learning" by Stephen Chappuis and Richard J. Stiggins
This model of evaluation is a means to success, not just a measure of it.
Journal of Curriculum and Supervision
July 1, 2004
51
"A Question of Authenticity: The Document-Based Question as an Assessment of Students' Knowledge of History" by S. G. Grant, Jill M. Gradwell, and Sandra K. Cim
ABSTRACT: In this article we consider the extent to which the Document-Based Question (DBQ) on the New York State Global History and Geography exam represents an authentic task. The DBQ seems </I...
Educational Leadership
March 1, 1999
43
"We Need Not Exclude Anyone" by Jacqueline Farmer Kearns et al.
Kentucky leads the way in demonstrating how students with exceptional needs can participate in a statewide assessment system.
Educational Leadership
October 1, 2004
39
"A Guide to Standardized Writing Assessment" by Doug Baldwin
With standardized writing tests here to stay, educators would do well to learn how their students' writing will be scored and how they can apply assessment techniques in their own classrooms.
Educational Leadership
November 1, 2003
36
"Learning from Student Assessment Results" by Nancy S. Sharkey and Richard J. Murnane
Teachers need more time and training to understand how to use data to improve achievement.
"How To" Books
January 1, 1994
34
How to Use Action Research in the Self-Renewing School
A book by Emily F. Calhoun (ASCD, 1994). Learning to inquire together, to generate knowledge and action simultaneously--that's action research. This book provides practical guidance for conducting...
Educational Leadership
September 1, 2002
64
"Classroom Assessment for Learning" by Stephen Chappuis and Richard J. Stiggins
This model of evaluation is a means to success, not just a measure of it.
Journal of Curriculum and Supervision
July 1, 2004
51
"A Question of Authenticity: The Document-Based Question as an Assessment of Students' Knowledge of History" by S. G. Grant, Jill M. Gradwell, and Sandra K. Cim
ABSTRACT: In this article we consider the extent to which the Document-Based Question (DBQ) on the New York State Global History and Geography exam represents an authentic task. The DBQ seems </I...
Educational Leadership
March 1, 1999
43
"We Need Not Exclude Anyone" by Jacqueline Farmer Kearns et al.
Kentucky leads the way in demonstrating how students with exceptional needs can participate in a statewide assessment system.
Educational Leadership
November 1, 2003
36
"Learning from Student Assessment Results" by Nancy S. Sharkey and Richard J. Murnane
Teachers need more time and training to understand how to use data to improve achievement.
"How To" Books
January 1, 1994
34
How to Use Action Research in the Self-Renewing School
A book by Emily F. Calhoun (ASCD, 1994). Learning to inquire together, to generate knowledge and action simultaneously--that's action research. This book provides practical guidance for conducting...
Educational Leadership
May 1, 2002
27
"A Defense of the Test for School Leaders" by John H. Holloway
The author tells how the assessment was developed and defends its use and effectiveness in licensing professional leaders.
Educational Leadership
March 1, 1999
27
"Using Assessments to Improve Equity in Mathematics" by Karen Cole et al.
In an Antarctica project, middle school students design a research station for scientists and learn to use assessments to extend their understanding of mathematics.
Journal of Curriculum and Supervision
April 1, 2002
26
"Juggling Two Sets of Books: A Teacher Responds to the New York State Global History Exam" by S. G. Grant et al.
New state curriculum and assessment policies broadcast a range of messages to teachers. In this case study of a 10th grade New York State global history teacher, we explore how she makes sense of one...
Educational Leadership
February 1, 2003
26
"How Classroom Assessments Improve Learning" by Thomas R. Guskey
The assessments most likely to improve student achievement are those that teachers create.
Update
April 1, 2002
25
"Assessing Assessment: Are Alternative Methods Making the Grade?" by John Franklin
Ken O'Connor knows the story well. A student in his school, after struggling as a freshman, turned around during her sophomore year and began steadily improving. By her junior year she was a...
"How To" Books
April 1, 2002
25
A Lexicon of Learning: What Educators Mean When They Say...
Ever wondered what educators mean when they refer to "authentic assessment" or "Bloom's Taxonomy"? Education, like all professions, has a specialized vocabulary that parents and others may have a...
Curriculum/Technology Quarterly
March 1, 2002
25
"Focus On: Health and Physical Education" by Kathy Checkley
Features "Making Assessment Meaningful in Physical Education": If you want to know how well Brenda plays tennis, you have to watch her play tennis. This seemingly obvious assessment...
Educational Leadership
September 1, 2004
22
"All About Accountability / Why Assessment Illiteracy Is Professional Suicide" by W. James Popham
Assessment literacy now ranks as one of our field's most fashionable phrases. Indeed, you can hardly attend any accountability conference these days without hearing someone extol the virtues of being...
Journal of Curriculum and Supervision
October 1, 1999
21
"The Educational and Political Implications of Curriculum Alignment and Standards-Based Reform" by William G. Wraga
This article examines major assumptions of curriculum alignment and standards-based reform. Curriculum alignment is analyzed against principles of and research on testing and evaluation and...
Educational Leadership
March 1, 1999
19
"Grading in a Standards-Based System" by Susan A. Colby
Elementary school teachers revised their reporting system to better assess their students' achievement of standards.
Educational Leadership
October 1, 2004
19
"The Negative Impact of Testing Writing Skills" by Paul Thomas
Be careful what you wish for. New writing components in standardized tests herald a setback in classroom writing practice.
Educational Leadership
February 1, 2000
18
"The Results We Want" by Mike Schmoker
We must move beyond a counter-productive criticism of standardized tests.